Up (2009) — Pixar DVD
Pixar's Up earns its emotional reputation without manipulation — the opening montage alone does more storytelling work than most features manage in two hours. A durable physical copy worth owning.
TL;DR Summary
Pros
- Opening montage is a masterclass in economical emotional storytelling
- Ed Asner and Christopher Plummer deliver voice performances with genuine weight
- Giacchino's score functions as a structural element, not just background texture
- Physical DVD format means permanent ownership with no streaming dependency
- Holds up across repeated viewings — details reward attention
Cons
- DVD transfer is adequate but not the format choice for a quality home theater setup — Blu-ray or 4K is preferable
- Third act leans into conventional action beats that don't fully match the emotional sophistication of the opening
- No notable bonus features mentioned for this edition
View Product
Check availability and current pricing
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Price shown ($9.59) reflects what we paid at time of purchase and may differ from current seller pricing.
Extended Observations
Pixar's Up earns its emotional reputation without manipulation — the opening montage alone does more storytelling work than most features manage in two hours. A durable physical copy worth owning.
Pete Docter's Up arrived in 2009 with enough critical momentum to make skepticism feel contrarian. Fifteen years on, it holds. The film opens with a wordless montage — Carl and Ellie's life together compressed into about four minutes — that operates at a register most animated films never attempt. It isn't cheap sentiment. It's efficient, precise filmmaking that trusts the audience to feel without being told what to feel.
The structure underneath that opening is a genuine adventure story: a grieving widower ties thousands of balloons to his house and floats to South America, with a stowaway Wilderness Explorer named Russell along for the ride. Ed Asner voices Carl with a convincing weight — the character's bitterness reads as earned, not cartoonish. Christopher Plummer's villain, Charles Muntz, gives the film a credible antagonist with his own warped logic about legacy and obsession.
Visually, the film rewards a good screen. The Venezuelan tepui landscapes have a lush, almost painterly quality, and the color palette shifts deliberately as Carl moves from grief toward something more open. Michael Giacchino's score — which won the Oscar — does real structural work rather than simply underlining the action. These are craft details that hold up on repeat viewings, which this film will get.
For the parent who wants a physical library that lasts, this DVD at under ten dollars is a reasonable acquisition. The disc format means no streaming license expiration, no buffering, no algorithm deciding it's been rotated out. This is the right format for a film you expect to watch more than twice.
A couple of caveats worth naming: the DVD transfer, while adequate, won't satisfy anyone with a calibrated 4K display — the Blu-ray or digital 4K version is the better call for picture quality. And the third act, while entertaining, doesn't quite match the emotional precision of the first twenty minutes. It resolves into a more conventional action sequence than the setup promises. Neither issue significantly diminishes what the film accomplishes overall.
Our Verdict
Pixar's Up earns its emotional reputation without manipulation — the opening montage alone does more storytelling work than most features manage in two hours. A durable physical copy worth owning.
Buy NowAffiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you
Discussion
0 commentsSign in to join the discussion
Sign inNo comments yet. Be the first to share.