OREO Cakesters Double Chocolate Snack Cakes
The Cakesters reboot delivers on nostalgia without leaning on it as a crutch — soft chocolate cake, cream filling, and a format that travels well. Worth keeping in the desk drawer.
TL;DR Summary
Pros
- Individual sealed packs preserve freshness effectively across the multipack's lifespan
- Double chocolate formulation delivers a cohesive, full-flavored chocolate experience rather than a thin novelty
- Soft cake format travels without crumbling — more durable in a bag than a standard cookie
- Portion size is sensible; two cakes per pack keeps it from becoming a mindless sleeve situation
- Familiar OREO flavor profile executed with enough fidelity to satisfy returning fans
Cons
- Sweetness level is pronounced — one pack is the natural stopping point for most adults
- Outer cardboard box offers minimal structural protection; not bag-ready without a secondary container
- Not a product for anyone expecting restraint in the ingredient list — this is unambiguously a processed snack
View Product
Check availability and current pricing
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Price shown ($7.99) reflects what we paid at time of purchase and may differ from current seller pricing.
Extended Observations
The Cakesters reboot delivers on nostalgia without leaning on it as a crutch — soft chocolate cake, cream filling, and a format that travels well. Worth keeping in the desk drawer.
OREO Cakesters disappeared from shelves in 2012, and their absence was felt more than most snack discontinuations. The original had a devoted following built on a simple premise: take the flavor logic of an OREO cookie and translate it into a soft, cake-based format. The Double Chocolate version coming back in individual snack packs suggests Nabisco understood what people actually missed.
The format here is five two-count packs, each sealed individually. That matters more than it sounds. The soft cake construction means moisture retention is everything — an unsealed pack goes stale fast, and a stale Cakester is a sad object. The individual wrapping keeps each serving fresh until you're ready for it, which makes the multipack practical for lunchboxes, desk drawers, or a bag that gets opened and closed repeatedly over a week.
The Double Chocolate variant layers cocoa into both the cake itself and the cream filling, which distinguishes it from the original vanilla-cream version. The result is a denser chocolate presence than you get from a standard OREO — less of a contrast between components, more of a unified chocolate experience. The cake has a fine, tight crumb and enough moisture to feel substantial without being cloying. The cream filling is the familiar OREO sweetness, dialed up slightly to hold its own against the chocolate cake.
The person this fits best is someone who wants a portion-controlled chocolate snack that doesn't require refrigeration and holds up in a bag without crumbling. Parents packing school lunches will find the individual sealing genuinely useful. The snack pack size — two cakes per pack — lands at a reasonable caloric footprint for a treat, which is harder to say about a full sleeve of cookies.
Two notes of caution: the sweetness level is real, and anyone sensitive to that will want to stop at one pack. And while the individual sealing is a strength, the outer multipack box is not particularly robust — worth transferring to a container if it's going into a backpack. Neither issue changes the overall picture. For what it is, the Cakester Double Chocolate earns its place back on shelves.
Our Verdict
The Cakesters reboot delivers on nostalgia without leaning on it as a crutch — soft chocolate cake, cream filling, and a format that travels well. Worth keeping in the desk drawer.
Buy NowAffiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you
Discussion
0 commentsSign in to join the discussion
Sign inNo comments yet. Be the first to share.